A translation update is in progress. Read the original Chinese version.

Comparative analysis of the global financial regulatory system: comprehensive interpretation by FCA, SEC, ASIC, MAS, CySEC, FINTRAC

  • Reading time:5 mins read

The focus of the global financial regulatory system is strong: the FCA is transparent, the SEC focuses on investor protection, the ASC is concerned with market order, the MAS has strong institutional advantages in the Asia-Pacific region, and CySEC is more flexible than FINTAC. This section compares comprehensively with compliance costs, applicable operations, regulatory intensity, application cycles, etc., and helps firms to choose regulatory systems appropriate to their own business model.


I. Why is global financial regulation at the heart of corporate compliance?

With the rapid development of cross-border financial, digital assets and multi-asset trading platforms, the global regulatory environment has become unprecedentedly complex.
For an enterprise to gain global customer confidence, the “regulated license level” has become the first criterion for the level of professionalism.

The importance of financial regulation is reflected in:

  • Enhancing international credibility
  • Reducing the risk of financial crime
  • Regulating internal corporate systems of control
  • Enhancing the legitimacy of cross-border payments/transactions
  • Access to more international financial services

The choice of an appropriate regulatory framework is therefore central to a long-term compliance strategy for an enterprise.


II. Description and characteristics of the six main mainstream regulatory bodies

The following six regulatory bodies, covering Eurasia and Eurasia, are currently the most common systems for enterprise applications:


United Kingdom FCA (Financial Compliance Authority) — World-class strong regulatory representative

Regulatory attributes: strong regulation / top credibility
Operational suitability: foreign exchange, securities, asset management, payments and financial technology

Advantages:

  • Global awareness is high and credibility is high.
  • Client funds protection (FSCS)
  • Market transparency is extremely high.
  • High level of professional competence of the institution

Suitable to a group of people:
International investment banks, brokers, asset management agencies, mature financial technology enterprises.


United States SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) — preferred by institutional investors

Regulatory attributes: one of the most stringent in the world
Operational suitability: RIA (Investment Adviser), fund management, securities services

Advantages:

  • Strict scrutiny of the nature of the controls and operations
  • Applicable institutional investor area
  • Top compliance endorsement in the world.

Characteristics:
The requirements of the SEC for operational transparency and compliance document structure are extremely high and industry thresholds are high, but they are also the most influential.


Australia ASIC (Australians Security & Investments Commission) — robustness and efficiency

Regulatory attributes: strong and medium-sized regulation
Fit for business: foreign exchange brokerage, financial derivatives, financial technology

Advantages:

  • Strictly regulated but efficient applications
  • Markets are highly globalized
  • Cost is much more manageable than Europe and America.

Fit for business:
There is a need to internationalize brand image while pursuing cost-effective trading-type enterprises.


Singapore MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore) — the highest level of regulation in Asia

Regulatory attributes: Asian top-level regulation
Suitable for business: payments, liquidation, digital assets, capital markets

Characteristics:

  • Regulatory systems are harmonized with the U.S. and UK.
  • A global lead in digital assets
  • High threshold, deep review, but very high gold content

Fit for business:
Enterprises that require very high levels of financial management and payment licence requirements.


Cyprus CySEC – EU passport advantage

Regulatory attributes: intermediate supervision (EU system)
Fit for business: foreign exchange brokerage, asset investment services

Advantages:

  • Licensed to operate across the European Union (passport rights)
  • More efficient applications
  • Relative flexibility in enterprise structure requirements

Fit for business:
A platform institution that wishes to enter the EU market but whose costs are manageable.


Canada FINTRAC MSB — low compliance threshold but extensive operations

Regulatory attributes: light regulation / clear compliance framework
Suitable for business: cryptocurrency, payments, convertibility, cross-border remittances, etc.

Advantages:

  • Short application cycle
  • The scope of application covers a wide range of modern financial operations
  • Lower cost

Fit for business:
The aim is to gain rapid access to international markets for payment and digital asset companies.


III. Core comparison of the six main regulatory systems (table version)

Regulatory systemRegulatory intensityDifficulty of applicationCost levelApplicable operationsFit for business
FCA⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐HighHighForeign exchange, asset management, paymentsLarge international financial institutions
SEC⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐HighHighInvestment consultants, fundsProfessional investment institutions
ASIC⭐⭐⭐⭐MediumMediumBrokers, financial technologyMedium-sized and large platforms
MAS⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐HighHighPayments, digital assetsHigh-end Asian institutions
CySEC⭐⭐⭐MediumMediumBrokersEU Business Enterprises
FINTRAC MSB⭐⭐LowLowPayment, Encrypted AssetsInitial / Grown-up Enterprises

How should enterprises choose the appropriate regulatory framework?

In selecting the regulatory system, it is recommended that the five dimensions be assessed as follows:

1 Where is the corporate target market?

Euro-American Client <unk>FCA / SEC
Asia-Pacific region MAS / ASIC
EU <unk> CySEC
FINTRAC MSB

2 Business type?

Category of transaction FCA / ASIC / CySEC
Payment category MAS / FINTRAC
INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENTS

3 Budget and Time?

Budgeted and branded
FINTRAC MSB
Balancing cost and regulation

4 Business plans for the next three years?

I want to be listed/internationalized.
I'd like to see a rapid expansion of middle/light regulation.


Summary: Regulatory levels affect the future competitiveness of enterprises

Selecting the right regulatory system not only affects enterprises:

  • International brand power
  • Compliance costs
  • Risk control capacity
  • Client trust
  • Cross-border operational capacity

More directly determines whether enterprises can grow steadily in the global financial sector in the long term.


VI. Need for professional assessment?

Covis Compliance (COVIS LTD)
Focusing on the assessment, planning and application of the global financial regulatory system.

✔ SEC / MSB / FCA / ASIC / MAS / CySEC
:: Enterprise compliance architecture development
:: Anti-money-laundering and internal control system
Control of applications for full process services